Comments on: Managing Review Comments In Author-it http://www.author-it.com/blog/2009/03/19/managing-review-comments-in-author-it/ The Author-it Software Corporation Corporate Blog Sun, 22 Jan 2012 20:51:29 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.2.1 By: HaxUplili http://www.author-it.com/blog/2009/03/19/managing-review-comments-in-author-it/#comment-3646 HaxUplili Tue, 17 May 2011 19:04:55 +0000 http://www.author-it.com/blog/?p=582#comment-3646 Hello people, just registered www.author-it.com . I've spent five days researching in the internet, right up until I have found this forum! I feel, I will certainly be here for a long time. kool forum. Hello people, just registered http://www.author-it.com . I’ve spent five days researching in the internet, right up until I have found this forum! I feel, I will certainly be here for a long time. kool forum.

]]> By: Amanda Caley http://www.author-it.com/blog/2009/03/19/managing-review-comments-in-author-it/#comment-2673 Amanda Caley Sat, 28 Mar 2009 13:14:32 +0000 http://www.author-it.com/blog/?p=582#comment-2673 I agree that this is not a suitable method for reviewers to enter their comments. This was never the intention of this tip. The intention is for the authors to have a small number of standard ‘review’ topics simply as placeholders. We use this method in situations where the reviewers are not providing their comments directly into Author-it. I agree that this is not a suitable method for reviewers to enter their comments. This was never the intention of this tip. The intention is for the authors to have a small number of standard ‘review’ topics simply as placeholders.

We use this method in situations where the reviewers are not providing their comments directly into Author-it.

]]> By: John Hawkins http://www.author-it.com/blog/2009/03/19/managing-review-comments-in-author-it/#comment-2670 John Hawkins Thu, 26 Mar 2009 17:17:29 +0000 http://www.author-it.com/blog/?p=582#comment-2670 My first thought was that this provides a nice way of separating review comments from topic content. But it does not really provide a clear method for reviewers to make comments. They could make comments directly in the main topic - in which case the comments are no longer separate - or in the embedded topic - which may be shared with other topics. I suppose a 2-level approach might work, with one topic holding standard review questions, embedded in another topic for comments that are specific to the main topic, and that is embedded in the main topic. But this means you'd have a lot of review topics! My first thought was that this provides a nice way of separating review comments from topic content. But it does not really provide a clear method for reviewers to make comments.

They could make comments directly in the main topic – in which case the comments are no longer separate – or in the embedded topic – which may be shared with other topics.

I suppose a 2-level approach might work, with one topic holding standard review questions, embedded in another topic for comments that are specific to the main topic, and that is embedded in the main topic. But this means you’d have a lot of review topics!

]]>